Reviewer Guidelines

Reviewer Guidelines

Thank you for reviewing for JITBI. Your expertise helps ensure the quality and validity of the research we publish.

The Review Process

JITBI uses a Double-Blind Peer Review process. This means the reviewer does not know the author's identity, and the author does not know the reviewer's identity.

Points to Consider

  1. Originality: Is the work novel and does it contribute to the field?
  2. Methodology: Is the research design appropriate and described in sufficient detail?
  3. Clarity: Is the writing clear, concise, and logical?
  4. References: Are the citations up-to-date (mostly last 5-10 years) and relevant?

Ethical Responsibilities

  • Treat the manuscript as confidential.
  • Be objective and constructive in your feedback.
  • Declare any potential conflicts of interest immediately.